Almost every positioning document arrives as a paragraph. It is well written, usually true, and almost never a decision. A decision is narrower: it says what the company is for, what it is not for, and what a customer can now do that they could not do before.

A paragraph describes. A decision rules things out.

If the statement does not exclude anything, it is not positioning. “We help modern teams work better” excludes no one, so it persuades no one. “We write incident communication for companies whose customers are engineers” excludes a great many people, and is useful precisely because of that.

The exclusion is not a marketing trick. It is how the product gets clearer: if the sentence rules out a segment, the roadmap can stop trying to serve it.

Start with the change, not the category

Categories are comfortable because they already have a vocabulary. But buyers do not buy a category; they buy a change in their week. A query engine that is twice as fast changes what you can afford to run. A deployment tool that removes a handover changes who is on call on Friday.

Our rule: write the change in one sentence, in the customer's verbs. If you cannot, the positioning problem is actually a product problem, and no paragraph will fix it.

If the sentence could be said by your three closest competitors, it is not positioning. It is weather.

The sentence is the last thing you write

We start with a list of decisions: who this is for, what it replaces, what we will not do, what proof exists. Then interviews — founders, engineers, the person who answers support. Then the last twenty sales calls, if they exist, because the questions buyers ask twice are the ones the site is not answering.

Only then the sentence. It is usually shorter than expected.

Three tests

  • Could a competitor say it? If yes, rewrite.
  • Could a customer repeat it after one call? If not, it is too abstract.
  • Could a salesperson defend it in a room where the CTO is sceptical? If not, there is no proof behind it.

Two out of three means the work is not finished. Three out of three means the homepage can be written in an afternoon.

What to do on Monday

Write down three things the company is not. Ask support which sentence they explain most often. Read the last ten sales emails and underline the question that repeats. Then write the one-sentence change, and leave it on the wall for a week before putting it on the site.

The paragraph is the easy part. The decision is the work.

This essay is part of our notes on positioning. If you want the decision made with you, the sprint is described in Services.